The Toast

Love is Buffering: Tuesday, October 7th, 2025

October 7, 2025

Key Takeaways Copied to clipboard!

  • Claudia Oshry documented a rare, extremely busy day for a Patreon vlog, emphasizing that her typical schedule revolves around hosting *The Toast* and spending time with her child. 
  • The hosts discussed Taylor Swift's appearance on *Jimmy Fallon*, noting her clarification that she would only perform the Super Bowl halftime show after Travis Kelce retires, and speculating on her recent change in makeup style potentially masking cosmetic work. 
  • Madison Beer and Justin Herbert publicly confirmed their romance with sideline PDA, leading to a discussion about the appealing 'pop star and football player' trope in celebrity relationships. 
  • The hosts believe Kacie's breakup with Patrick from *Love is Blind* was primarily due to a lack of physical attraction, despite her attempts to frame it around other issues. 
  • The *Love is Blind* season being discussed is characterized by significant relationship turmoil, particularly concerning attraction issues and highly uncomfortable interpersonal conflicts among the couples. 
  • The advice segment strongly suggests that a professional baseball player only inviting a woman to hang out at 10 p.m. without having had sex indicates she is being treated as a 'booty call.' 

Segments

Opening Banter and Life Updates
Copied to clipboard!
(00:00:03)
  • Key Takeaway: Claudia is relocating across the country due to her husband’s request, prompting Jackie to acknowledge the sacrifice involved in being a supportive wife.
  • Summary: The hosts opened The Toast episode for Tuesday, October 7th, 2025, with casual greetings and personal updates. Claudia shared that she is moving across the country because her husband asked her to. Jackie noted that Tuesdays are now exciting due to Dancing with the Stars airing that evening.
Claudia’s Busy Day Vlog
Copied to clipboard!
(00:01:20)
  • Key Takeaway: Claudia vlogged her busiest day, which included speaking on a star-studded panel at Advertising Week, and she clarified that such days are exceptions to her normal routine of focusing on The Toast and her child.
  • Summary: Claudia’s vlog, available on the Patreon, detailed a rare, exceptionally busy day where she spoke on a panel sandwiched between Love Island personalities and Kevin Bacon. She stressed that listeners should not assume this level of activity is typical, as she usually prioritizes her child and podcast work. The vlog also covers her pumping and feeding schedule.
Sister Reunion Surprise
Copied to clipboard!
(00:03:30)
  • Key Takeaway: Claudia was genuinely shocked to see a photo of her sisters Olivia and Satchel together at Advertising Week because Satchel’s attendance was a surprise arranged by Olivia.
  • Summary: Claudia felt a strange sense of exclusion seeing her three sisters (Olivia, Satchel, and herself) together in a photo, realizing she was absent from the Advertising Week event. Satchel, Claudia’s social media manager, was surprised by Olivia, who gave her an extra lanyard to attend the conference.
Love Island Interaction Review
Copied to clipboard!
(00:05:24)
  • Key Takeaway: Despite previously criticizing Nick on Love Island, Claudia found him to be exceptionally tall, handsome, and kind when meeting him backstage at the event.
  • Summary: Claudia admitted that meeting Nick from Love Island changed her perspective, as he treated everyone with kindness and had no idea who she was, unlike others who might be informed about her podcast status. She maintains that his actions toward Sierra were wrong, but his personal demeanor was lovely.
Taylor Swift on Jimmy Fallon
Copied to clipboard!
(00:10:10)
  • Key Takeaway: Taylor Swift addressed rumors on Jimmy Fallon, confirming Ed Sheeran learned of her engagement via Instagram and explaining her Super Bowl commitment hinges on Travis Kelce’s football schedule.
  • Summary: Taylor Swift appeared on Jimmy Fallon to clear up five pre-approved rumors, including one about Ed Sheeran. She clarified that she prioritizes supporting Travis Kelce’s career, stating she would not perform the Super Bowl halftime show while he is actively playing football. Claudia theorized that Taylor’s switch to a nude lip during this appearance might be a strategic distraction following a recent cosmetic tune-up.
Madison Beer and Justin Herbert PDA
Copied to clipboard!
(00:28:15)
  • Key Takeaway: Madison Beer and Justin Herbert confirmed their relationship status with public sideline PDA, reinforcing the popular celebrity trope of pop stars dating football players.
  • Summary: Madison Beer’s presence and kissing on the sidelines confirmed her relationship with Chargers QB Justin Herbert, which Jackie celebrated as fitting the ‘pop star and football player’ trope. Jackie listed other couples fitting this dynamic, such as Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce, and noted that the Chiefs lost their game the previous night.
NFL Team Relevance Debate
Copied to clipboard!
(00:29:57)
  • Key Takeaway: The hosts categorized most NFL teams as ‘supporting roles’ or ‘irrelevant’ unless they are major market teams or consistently winning, citing the Jaguars and Panthers as examples of non-main characters.
  • Summary: The conversation devolved into ranking NFL team relevance, suggesting that teams like the Titans, Cardinals, and Panthers feel like minor league teams supporting the main characters (Chiefs, Giants, Cowboys, etc.). Trevor Lawrence was highlighted as a popular quarterback despite his team’s perceived lack of success, leading to a debate over why non-winning quarterbacks gain such popularity.
Instagram Creator Awards Launch
Copied to clipboard!
(00:36:23)
  • Key Takeaway: Instagram is launching ‘Rings,’ an awards program recognizing 25 creators with both physical and digital golden rings for their profile, aiming to celebrate platform-specific creativity.
  • Summary: Instagram is introducing the ‘Rings’ awards to honor creators who take creative risks on the platform, with only 25 recipients receiving a physical award and a unique digital golden ring badge. Claudia expressed hope that the awards would go to genuine platform creators rather than established celebrities who might only post content sporadically.
J.Lo and Ben Affleck Reunion
Copied to clipboard!
(00:40:14)
  • Key Takeaway: Jennifer Lopez and Ben Affleck made a surprise reunion appearance on the red carpet for Kiss of the Spider-Woman, which Ben Affleck produced, though J.Lo reacted defensively when asked about it publicly.
  • Summary: Jennifer Lopez appeared surprised when interviewed about walking the red carpet with her ex-husband, Ben Affleck, despite the public nature of the appearance. The film, which J.Lo stars in as the fictional diva Ingrid Luna, was produced by Ben Affleck and Matt Damon’s company, Artist Equity. Claudia noted that J.Lo has strategically taken a break from making what Claudia considers to be poor-quality movies.
Love is Blind Denver Critique
Copied to clipboard!
(00:07:35)
  • Key Takeaway: The current season of Love is Blind filmed in Denver is reflecting poorly on the city’s dating scene, suggesting the Coloradans are an ‘unwell group of people’ compared to previous seasons.
  • Summary: The hosts feel the Denver cast is representing Colorado poorly, contrasting them with the seemingly normal participants from the Chicago season. Claudia worries the behavior displayed might negatively impact perceptions of Colorado’s progressive reputation, particularly regarding marijuana legalization. The segment concluded with a brief mention of Joe and his choice, which Claudia watched in blurry quality due to Wi-Fi issues.
Buy Heart Formula Ad Read
Copied to clipboard!
(00:46:15)
  • Key Takeaway: Buy Heart offers a single infant formula made with organic breast-fed whole milk and a patented protein blend, backed by breast milk science.
  • Summary: Buy Heart’s infant formula is clinically proven and uses organic breast-fed whole milk instead of skim. The company focuses on one formula, which they claim is the closest to breast milk due to extensive research. Listeners can use code Toast30 for 30% off their first subscription order at buyheart.com.
Kacie and Patrick Breakup Analysis
Copied to clipboard!
(00:47:37)
  • Key Takeaway: Kacie felt Patrick was a ‘stranger’ upon meeting him, realizing physical attraction did not grow, leading to her calculated charade to avoid admitting looks were the issue.
  • Summary: Kacie stated she felt Patrick was a stranger when they met, realizing the attraction could not grow, which is a major issue for her. The hosts suspect Kacie staged overly affectionate behavior to mask her lack of attraction to avoid appearing shallow. Her biggest regret is confusing Patrick by trying to protect his feelings instead of being direct.
Madison and Joe Attraction Issues
Copied to clipboard!
(00:52:24)
  • Key Takeaway: Madison exhibits needy and insecure energy by constantly seeking validation from Joe regarding her looks and love, which is unattractive.
  • Summary: The hosts feel Madison’s constant need for reassurance about her attractiveness and love is a sign of deep insecurity. Joe’s repeated negative comments about Madison’s looks, despite having sex with her, are noted. The hosts believe Madison is making the situation worse by waking Joe up during a blackout stupor to have serious conversations.
Megan and Jordan Financial Disparity
Copied to clipboard!
(00:54:29)
  • Key Takeaway: The financial disparity between wealthy Megan and self-proclaimed ‘poor’ Jordan mirrors the uncomfortable real-life financial conflicts seen in the Amber and Barnett dynamic from Season 1.
  • Summary: Megan constantly emphasizes her wealth while Jordan proudly emphasizes his poverty, creating a significant socioeconomic gap. Jordan’s judgmental behavior towards Megan’s ‘Sparkle’ persona and habits, like turning off the sink, suggests he is being a ‘dick’ rather than just being proud of his own frugality. Despite this, the hosts believe Megan was right to choose Jordan over the ‘sinister’ Mike.
Jordan’s Immaturity vs. Mike’s Sinister Vibe
Copied to clipboard!
(00:57:03)
  • Key Takeaway: Jordan exhibits immature, ‘boy side’ behavior with friends, but he is a genuinely nice guy who apologizes when confronted, unlike the ‘sinister’ Mike.
  • Summary: Jordan’s immaturity when drinking or with friends is seen as a major ‘ick,’ though he responds well to direct criticism from Megan. Mike is perceived as a potential con man who may have been attracted to Megan’s wealth, making Jordan the safer choice. Jordan’s approach to Megan’s doubts made her feel good, contrasting sharply with Mike’s behavior.
Annie and Nick Relationship Status
Copied to clipboard!
(00:58:50)
  • Key Takeaway: Annie and Nick are surprisingly the best couple, though Nick must disclose telling two women he loved them in the pods before meeting Annie.
  • Summary: Annie and Nick are considered the most functional couple despite Nick’s past actions, which will likely surface when they meet the rest of the cast. Nick’s job as a luxury watch dealer explains his knowledge of Annie’s Cartier bracelet. Annie is described as sweet and slightly ‘hairbrained’ but has become more serious as the season progressed.
Pod Sex and Season Openness
Copied to clipboard!
(00:59:42)
  • Key Takeaway: This season of Love is Blind featured an unusual level of explicit sexual discussion in the pods, with most couples confirming they had sex on the honeymoons except for Calibria and Edmund.
  • Summary: The hosts noted a high volume of sexual talk in the pods this season, exemplified by Kacie’s detailed comments about her pubic hair. Most couples confirmed having sex in Mexico, with Madison/Joe and Annie/Nick being surprising pairings in that regard. Calibria revealing Allie’s period status was deemed an extremely inappropriate moment that highlighted the show’s current insanity.
Overall Season Outlook and Strongest Couple
Copied to clipboard!
(01:02:04)
  • Key Takeaway: The current season of Love is Blind is viewed as a ‘sinking ship’ with a high probability of zero marriages, with Annie and Nick being the only viable couple.
  • Summary: The extreme nature of the show’s concept is being highlighted by the current season’s chaotic dynamics, leading to doubts about any marriages occurring. The hosts list several couples whose relationships are clearly failing, including Casey/Patrick and Madison/Joe, who need to break up immediately. Annie and Nick are considered the strongest, despite Nick’s past secrets, while Calibria and Edmund’s argument over hypothetical violence revealed deep differences.
Dear Toasters Advice Segment
Copied to clipboard!
(01:04:53)
  • Key Takeaway: A woman dating a professional baseball player who only schedules dates at 10 p.m. is advised that she is being used as a booty call and should not expect commitment.
  • Summary: The advice segment strongly asserts that the athlete’s consistent 10 p.m. meeting time, despite being attentive otherwise, means the inquirer is only a booty call. The hosts advise against wasting time waiting for the season to end, as dating professional athletes rarely leads to long-term commitment unless one waits many years. The advice suggests either having fun with the situation or refusing to engage sexually to force clarity from the athlete.