The Toast

Re-Signing NOT Resigning: Wednesday, October 1st, 2025

October 1, 2025

Key Takeaways Copied to clipboard!

  • The hosts of The Toast announced they have successfully re-signed their contract with Dear Media, emphasizing they are 're-signing' rather than 'resigning'. 
  • Claudia shared the personal news that she got her period for the first time in 413 days, marking a 'renewal' theme alongside their contract renewal and the upcoming Day of Atonement. 
  • The hosts plan to cover the recent *Dancing with the Stars* episode, the rumored Keith Urban/Nicole Kidman split, and Luke Combs' surprise music release in the remainder of the episode. 
  • The hosts dedicated a significant portion of this segment of "The Toast" episode "Re-Signing NOT Resigning: Wednesday, October 1st, 2025" to a detailed recap and critique of the recent "Dancing with the Stars" TikTok Night, focusing heavily on contestant performances, professional dancer dynamics, and the perceived over-promotion of TikTok. 
  • The discussion highlighted strong support for contestants like Andy Richter, whose improvement and positive attitude are resonating with viewers, contrasting with criticism aimed at the judging disparity, particularly regarding professional dancers like Whitney Carson. 
  • The segment included advertisements for Branch Basics cleaning products and Happy Egg, emphasizing the hosts' personal endorsements for these brands. 

Segments

Podcast Introduction and Day Context
Copied to clipboard!
(00:00:04)
  • Key Takeaway: The hosts acknowledge the current day feels like Tuesday due to Dancing with the Stars airing on Monday.
  • Summary: The hosts greet listeners and establish the current day’s context, noting the confusion between Tuesday and Wednesday because Dancing with the Stars airs on Monday. They confirm there will be no show the following day due to the Day of Atonement. This day marks their annual episode for reflection and atonement for sins.
Atonement and Contract Renewal
Copied to clipboard!
(00:01:46)
  • Key Takeaway: Claudia apologized for causing listeners to laugh so hard while driving that they endangered themselves.
  • Summary: Claudia offered an apology for causing listeners to laugh dangerously while driving, though she admitted she likely won’t change. The major announcement followed: the hosts have successfully re-signed their three-year contract with Dear Media. They confirmed that the production will remain a Dear Media Production, but their established intro and content style will remain unchanged.
Claudia’s Period Return
Copied to clipboard!
(00:04:03)
  • Key Takeaway: Claudia unexpectedly got her period after 413 days postpartum, coinciding with their contract renewal.
  • Summary: Claudia revealed she got her period unexpectedly while wearing her hydrangea pajamas, marking her first period in 413 days (since August 18th of the previous year). She noted that the experience felt less painful than before pregnancy, possibly due to heightened tolerance. The hosts framed this bodily event as symbolic of ‘renewal’ alongside their new contract.
Period Sweater History
Copied to clipboard!
(00:08:36)
  • Key Takeaway: The hosts clarified the history of Claudia’s two distinct ‘period sweaters’ based on color and stripe patterns.
  • Summary: Jackie referenced Claudia’s ‘period sweater,’ leading to a clarification of which one she meant, as Claudia has owned two. The first was a dual-tone pink and red sweater, and the second featured many dark stripes symbolizing different days. Jackie suggested buying a new ‘period sweater’ to signify Claudia’s new cycle.
Episode Preview and Atonement Part 2
Copied to clipboard!
(00:11:10)
  • Key Takeaway: Jackie expressed her desire to work on being less snappy and short-tempered, acknowledging it might be related to new motherhood.
  • Summary: The hosts previewed upcoming segments, including a Dancing with the Stars recap and the Keith Urban/Nicole Kidman update. When discussing what she is atoning for, Jackie admitted she wants to leave behind being ‘snappy’ and ‘short-tempered,’ feeling she needs to prioritize friendships more once she recovers from the current season of life. She gave herself grace, recognizing this is not the time for major personal change.
Sponsor Reads: ByHeart, Factor, Quince
Copied to clipboard!
(00:15:04)
  • Key Takeaway: ByHeart formula uses a patented protein blend closest to breast milk, Factor offers chef-prepped meals with 50% off plus free breakfast for a year, and Quince provides luxury essentials at half the price.
  • Summary: ByHeart is highlighted for using organic grass-fed whole milk and a patented protein blend in their single infant formula offering. Factor meals are praised for convenience, especially for breastfeeding mothers, with a deal offering 50% off the first box plus free breakfast for a year using code TOAST50OFF. Quince offers high-quality wardrobe staples like cashmere sweaters starting at $50, with free shipping via code TOAST.
Keith Urban and Nicole Kidman Split
Copied to clipboard!
(00:19:34)
  • Key Takeaway: Rumors suggest Keith Urban’s split from Nicole Kidman was triggered by another woman, evidenced by him changing song lyrics to reference his new guitar player, Maggie.
  • Summary: Reports indicate Keith Urban is allegedly seeing another woman, which Nicole Kidman is reportedly shocked by, despite filing for divorce. A resurfaced video showed Urban changing lyrics in his song ‘Fighter’ from referencing Nicole to referencing his guitar player, Maggie, which the hosts deemed a strange move. Financial context revealed Nicole Kidman’s net worth ($250M) significantly exceeds Keith Urban’s ($75M) due to her film salaries, producing power, and endorsements.
Luke Combs Surprise Music Drop
Copied to clipboard!
(00:29:12)
  • Key Takeaway: Luke Combs is releasing a three-song EP titled The Prequel this Friday, showing no fear of competing with Taylor Swift’s recent album dominance.
  • Summary: Luke Combs is releasing three new songs, including ‘My Kind of Saturday Night’ and ‘Days Like These,’ despite Taylor Swift’s continued chart occupation. The hosts view this as disruptive but exciting, noting Combs is releasing music because fans want it, not due to corporate pressure. The snippet of ‘Days Like These’ had already gone viral on TikTok, prompting the release.
Brooks Nader and Sister Drama
Copied to clipboard!
(00:34:43)
  • Key Takeaway: Brooks Nader’s sister, Grace Ann, blocked her after revealing Brooks’ relationship with Carlos Alcaraz on a radio show.
  • Summary: Grace Ann revealed on a radio show that she exposed Brooks Nader’s relationship with Carlos Alcaraz, leading Brooks to block her temporarily. Grace Ann defended her actions by claiming she has no filter, especially when living with Brooks. The sisters are reportedly fine now, with Grace Ann having joined Brooks in Paris, though the hosts found the public betrayal messy.
L’Oreal Fashion Show Recap
Copied to clipboard!
(00:36:54)
  • Key Takeaway: Molly Mae Hague walked in the L’Oreal fashion show this year after declining to walk the previous year due to postpartum confidence issues.
  • Summary: Molly Mae Hague walked the L’Oreal show this year, contrasting with last year when she declined to walk, citing a lack of confidence following the birth of her child, Bambi. There was minor online speculation about tension between Molly Mae and Bethany Hamilton on the runway, as Bethany reportedly posed too long, delaying Molly Mae’s turn. Molly Mae also debuted a new bob haircut at the event.
Lola Young Health Cancellation
Copied to clipboard!
(00:40:18)
  • Key Takeaway: Lola Young canceled all upcoming events to ‘work on myself’ after collapsing on stage in New York, leading to speculation about her health struggles.
  • Summary: Lola Young collapsed during a concert, and she later released a statement apologizing for cancellations and promising to return stronger after working on herself. The hosts noted that her tour theme, ‘Messy,’ aligns with her public struggles, and a TikTok comment pointed out her manager is the same as Amy Winehouse’s, who also discovered both artists.
Sponsor Reads: Opil and Kettle & Fire
Copied to clipboard!
(00:44:12)
  • Key Takeaway: Opil is the first FDA-approved over-the-counter daily birth control pill, safe for use while breastfeeding, and Kettle & Fire offers grass-fed bone broth with up to 19 grams of protein.
  • Summary: Opil is an estrogen-free, full-prescription-strength daily birth control pill available OTC, addressing barriers many women face accessing prescriptions. Kettle & Fire bone broth supports gut health and recovery, made from grass-fed beef or free-range chicken bones, with a limited-time offer for a free carton upon purchasing three.
Branch Basics & Happy Egg Ads
Copied to clipboard!
(00:47:58)
  • Key Takeaway: Branch Basics offers an accessible, non-toxic cleaning solution, and Happy Egg yolks are naturally neon orange, contrasting with pale store-bought eggs.
  • Summary: Branch Basics products are presented as affordable and aesthetically pleasing, with listeners encouraged to use code ’toast’ for 15% off the premium starter kit. Happy Egg hens are pasture-raised, resulting in vibrant orange yolks that signify higher quality compared to ‘sad eggs’ from confined hens. Listeners can find Happy Egg locations by visiting happyegg.com/slash toast.
DWTS TikTok Night Recap
Copied to clipboard!
(00:50:17)
  • Key Takeaway: The ‘Dancing with the Stars’ TikTok Night felt overly promotional, suggesting a paid partnership with TikTok, which confused viewers accustomed to the show’s broader appeal.
  • Summary: The episode featured a shocking elimination, though one host argued it was deserved based on low scores, noting Andy Richter was tied with the eliminated contestant but is improving. The theme was criticized for being too heavily branded, with the show explaining TikTok to its older audience, leading to speculation it was a paid promotion involving the TikTok logo.
Contestant Performance Analysis
Copied to clipboard!
(00:53:05)
  • Key Takeaway: Choreography quality significantly influences scores, with Whitney Carson being praised for maximizing Robert Irwin’s potential, while Elaine’s performance was deemed a creative failure.
  • Summary: Scott Hoying received an eight despite not being the strongest dancer, credited to his partner Riley’s performance, highlighting the pro’s influence on the overall score. Elaine’s dance, outfit, and music choice were heavily criticized as a ‘mess’ and not fitting her persona. The disparity between professional dancers, like Whitney Carson versus newer pros partnered with established stars like Jennifer Affleck, is noted as unfair.
Pro Dancer Dynamics and Favoritism
Copied to clipboard!
(00:54:42)
  • Key Takeaway: There is perceived unfairness in professional dancer pairings, with veteran pros like Mark Ballas and Whitney Carson often paired with high-potential contestants, while newcomers are given less experienced partners.
  • Summary: Twitter drama suggests Mark Ballas cherry-picks partners, often winning with established social media stars like Charlie D’Amelio. Jennifer Affleck is considered unfairly paired with a newbie pro, suggesting she should have been matched with a veteran like Whitney Carson or Hilaria. Hilaria Baldwin is noted for her technical skill but is considered at risk due to a lack of fan votes.
Andy Richter’s Unexpected Popularity
Copied to clipboard!
(01:07:41)
  • Key Takeaway: Andy Richter is succeeding due to his commitment to improvement and the ‘cute older man energy’ choreographed by Emma, earning him significant fan support despite low technical skill.
  • Summary: Andy Richter’s performance, set to Northern Attitude, leaned into spreading joy, which moved one host to tears. His momentum is considered unbeatable by fan base, ensuring he will last several more weeks. Emma is praised for choreographing perfectly to his abilities, making him great television.
Robert Irwin’s Appeal and DWTS Wrap
Copied to clipboard!
(01:09:38)
  • Key Takeaway: Robert Irwin’s dance to ‘Million Dollar Baby’ was visually impressive, and he was revealed to have the most TikTok followers among the cast, making him the season’s eligible bachelor.
  • Summary: One host admitted finding Robert Irwin handsome only after seeing him shirtless during his performance, noting his age is around 21. Whitney Carson’s choreography was deemed ‘insane’ and perhaps too advanced for the show’s level. The hosts concluded the recap, wished Jewish listeners well for Yom Kippur, and promoted new Patreon content.