The Toast

The Toastoween I Turned Pretty: Friday, October 31st, 2025

October 31, 2025

Key Takeaways Copied to clipboard!

  • The hosts, dressed in costumes referencing characters from 'The Summer I Turned Pretty' (Belly, Conrad Fisher, and Jeremiah), dedicate a significant portion of the episode to roleplaying and discussing the show's dynamics, despite Ben not having seen it. 
  • Dictionary.com's 2025 Word of the Year was announced as the viral, largely nonsensical phrase '6'7,' which the hosts find indicative of the declining quality of such annual selections. 
  • The hosts discussed celebrity news including Megan Thee Stallion and Klay Thompson buying a house together, and Jesse Eisenberg's altruistic decision to donate a kidney to a stranger. 
  • The hosts engaged in a lengthy, humorous discussion about the TV show *The Summer I Turned Pretty*, specifically debating which character (Conrad or Jeremiah) Belly would choose, culminating in a decision to give a kidney to Jeremiah. 
  • The conversation devolved into a playful argument over the character name 'Conrad,' with one host mistakenly calling him 'Connie' and leading to a humorous tangent about the name's perceived persona. 
  • The segment concluded with the hosts expressing satisfaction with their 'Toastoween' episode, thanking listeners, and promoting subscriptions and reviews for *The Toast* across all platforms. 

Segments

Halloween Costumes and Show Roleplay
Copied to clipboard!
(00:00:31)
  • Key Takeaway: The hosts adopted characters from ‘The Summer I Turned Pretty’ for Halloween, with Ben playing Conrad Fisher and Margo playing Jeremiah, while Claudia was Belly.
  • Summary: The hosts initiated the episode in character as figures from ‘The Summer I Turned Pretty,’ specifically referencing Conrad Fisher, Jeremiah, and Belly. Ben noted that he had never seen the show, requiring Margo and Claudia to explain character details like Belly’s mother, Laurel. The roleplay included lighthearted conflict over who ‘owns’ Belly.
Costume Critique and Character Comparisons
Copied to clipboard!
(00:01:47)
  • Key Takeaway: The hosts critiqued each other’s Halloween costumes, comparing Ben’s look to Ellen DeGeneres and Margo’s to Jeremiah and Annie.
  • Summary: The hosts evaluated their costumes, with Ben’s appearance being compared to Ellen DeGeneres with a mole, and Margo’s look being likened to Jeremiah. Ben’s wig prompted discussion about his appearance, leading to comparisons with Ina Garten and Annie. The segment concluded with Ben admitting he is unfamiliar with the show’s plot beyond the general premise.
Belly’s Nickname and Character Wealth
Copied to clipboard!
(00:06:00)
  • Key Takeaway: Belly’s real name is Isabelle, and the nickname ‘Belly’ is considered a terrible nickname only suitable for a thin person.
  • Summary: The hosts clarified that Belly’s full name is Isabelle and debated the suitability of the nickname, concluding it is only acceptable because the character is thin. They established that Conrad and Jeremiah are brothers whose mother is Suzanne, and they are wealthy due to their father’s investment fund. Conversely, Belly comes from a financially stable but divorced home, contrasting with the perception that she is poor.
Sponsor Read: Byhart Infant Formula
Copied to clipboard!
(00:14:54)
  • Key Takeaway: Byhart is an infant nutrition company using breast milk science, organic grass-fed whole milk, and a patented protein blend to create an easy-to-digest formula.
  • Summary: Byhart aims to create the best infant formula globally by incorporating the latest breast milk science. Their gentle recipe features clean ingredients and is made with organic grass-fed whole milk. Listeners can use the code TOAST30 for 30% off their first subscription order at buyheart.com.
Dictionary.com Word of the Year
Copied to clipboard!
(00:16:22)
  • Key Takeaway: Dictionary.com named the viral, ambiguous phrase ‘6'7’ as the 2025 Word of the Year, which some interpret as meaning ‘so-so’ or ‘mid.’
  • Summary: The hosts reacted strongly to Dictionary.com naming ‘6'7’ as the 2025 Word of the Year, noting it is derived from a song lyric and is largely nonsensical. The term is used by Gen Alpha as slippery slang, sometimes meaning ‘so-so’ or used randomly in response to seeing the numbers 67. The hosts expressed disdain for Dictionary.com’s choice compared to Merriam-Webster’s selections.
Megan Thee Stallion and Klay Thompson News
Copied to clipboard!
(00:22:06)
  • Key Takeaway: Megan Thee Stallion and NBA star Klay Thompson (who plays for the Dallas Mavericks) bought a house together, prompting discussion on athlete contract values.
  • Summary: The couple’s relationship milestone was noted, leading to a debate over which sport yields the highest player contracts, with the NBA and NFL being primary contenders. The hosts agreed that soccer players like Messi earn massive salaries, but football players might earn the most per game played. Klay Thompson benefits from playing in Texas, which has no state income tax.
DWTS Drama: Max Chmerkovskiy Apology
Copied to clipboard!
(00:27:37)
  • Key Takeaway: Maks Chmerkovskiy apologized to Jan Ravnik after comments on his podcast and invited him to ‘bury the hatchet,’ which Jan publicly dismissed as an attempt to stay relevant.
  • Summary: Maks Chmerkovskiy issued a public apology to Jan Ravnik following controversial remarks, inviting him to meet privately. Jan reportedly stated the comments did not hurt his feelings and implied Maks was seeking relevance. The hosts also noted that Val Chmerkovskiy diplomatically distanced himself from his brother’s comments.
DWTS Reunion and TV Streaming Issues
Copied to clipboard!
(00:29:50)
  • Key Takeaway: Ashley Tisdale and Kenny Ortega reunited at ‘Dancing with the Stars’ to support Dylan Efron, while the hosts lamented losing ABC and ESPN channels on YouTube TV.
  • Summary: Ashley Tisdale and Kenny Ortega were seen together supporting Dylan Efron’s performance on ‘Dancing with the Stars,’ sparking High School Musical nostalgia. The hosts expressed frustration over the recent breakdown in negotiations between YouTube TV and Disney/ABC, meaning they can no longer watch live ABC content like ‘Dancing with the Stars’ on that platform.
Jesse Eisenberg’s Kidney Donation
Copied to clipboard!
(00:37:33)
  • Key Takeaway: Actor Jesse Eisenberg announced he is donating one of his kidneys to a total stranger in mid-December as an altruistic donation.
  • Summary: Jesse Eisenberg revealed on the ‘Today Show’ that he is scheduled for an altruistic kidney donation in six weeks, meaning he is matched with a recipient he does not know. He described the decision as a ’no-brainer’ after getting ‘bitten by the blood donation bug.’ The hosts expressed awe at the gesture but questioned the long-term health implications of living with only one kidney.
Kidney Donation Hypothetical
Copied to clipboard!
(00:39:19)
  • Key Takeaway: The hosts debated hypothetical kidney donation choices between Conrad and Jeremiah from The Summer I Turned Pretty.
  • Summary: The discussion centered on a hypothetical scenario where Belly must choose which of the two main male characters, Conrad or Jeremiah, receives a kidney if only one can be saved. One host ultimately decided to give the kidney to Jeremiah, leading to immediate dramatic reactions regarding the fate of Conrad.
Conrad Name Confusion
Copied to clipboard!
(00:40:06)
  • Key Takeaway: The character Conrad Fisher was repeatedly misidentified as ‘Connie,’ leading to a humorous debate over the name’s gender association.
  • Summary: The confusion over calling Conrad ‘Connie’ prompted a side discussion where one host asserted that ‘Connie’ sounds like a stereotypical woman’s name, like ‘Karen in Walmart.’ This led to a suggestion that Ben should create a TikTok based on the ‘Connie’ persona.
Pivotal Show Scene Analysis
Copied to clipboard!
(00:40:38)
  • Key Takeaway: A specific, emotionally charged scene from The Summer I Turned Pretty involving a funeral, yelling, and a character falling was recalled.
  • Summary: The hosts referenced a pivotal moment where Belly has a mental breakdown at a funeral, yells at Conrad in front of everyone at his mother’s wake (Shiva), and subsequently falls down. The scene is underscored by the song ‘Time Casts a Spell on You.’
Belly’s Belly Button Observation
Copied to clipboard!
(00:41:56)
  • Key Takeaway: One host commented extensively on the physical appearance of Belly’s belly button, describing it as ‘vast’ and ‘deep.’
  • Summary: During the song lyrics recitation, the conversation abruptly focused on Belly’s physical attributes, specifically her belly button, which was described in detail by one of the hosts. This observation was followed by a brief, confusing mention of characters named Lacey and Laurel.
Episode Wrap-up and Promotion
Copied to clipboard!
(00:42:30)
  • Key Takeaway: The hosts concluded the ‘Toastoween’ episode, expressed satisfaction with the outcome despite missing a regular co-host, and directed listeners to subscribe and leave reviews.
  • Summary: The hosts confirmed they successfully executed the Halloween-themed episode, ‘Toastoween,’ even without Jackie present, and felt they ‘crushed’ it. They encouraged the audience to subscribe on YouTube and leave five-star reviews on podcast platforms.