The Big Picture

The Daniel Day-Lewis Hall of Fame

October 10, 2025

Key Takeaways Copied to clipboard!

  • The hosts and guest David Sims agree that the 2025 film slate, particularly the fall festival offerings, feels like a "flop fall" with only a few original efforts resonating strongly. 
  • Daniel Day-Lewis's new film, *Anemone*, directed by his son Ronan Day-Lewis, is considered visually beautiful but ultimately an unsuccessful film that failed to justify the actor's return from retirement. 
  • Daniel Day-Lewis's career is defined by his commitment to transformation, period pieces, and the Method, contrasting sharply with contemporary British actors known for less immersive, more volatile on-set behavior. 
  • Daniel Day-Lewis's early career included roles like the one in the 1986 French romantic drama *Nanu* (likely a misidentification for a film like *My Beautiful Laundrette* or another early work, as *Nanu* is not widely recognized in his filmography) and the 1988 film *The Unbearable Lightness of Being*, where he played a surprisingly sex-forward 'lothario' role he seemingly avoided later. 
  • The 1988 comedy *Stars and Bars* is considered a significant low point in Daniel Day-Lewis's filmography, where his attempt at contemporary comedy failed, contrasting sharply with the critical success and physical transformation showcased in his next film, *My Left Foot*. 
  • The period between *My Left Foot* (1989) and *Gangs of New York* (2002) established Daniel Day-Lewis's reputation for intense physical transformation and method acting, exemplified by his Oscar win and the subsequent 'mythic stuff' surrounding his preparation for roles like Hawkeye in *The Last of the Mohicans* (1992). 
  • Daniel Day-Lewis's performance as Bill the Butcher in *Gangs of New York* is considered one of the greatest Scorsese performances, despite the film itself being described as a 'Frankenstein of a movie.' 
  • The discussion confirms that *Lincoln* (2012) is a definitive entry for Daniel Day-Lewis's Hall of Fame, marking his third Oscar win and Spielberg's first acting win for one of his actors. 
  • *Phantom Thread* (2017) is highly regarded by the hosts as both a favorite Paul Thomas Anderson film and a surprisingly hilarious comedy, despite reports that the role was intensely difficult for Day-Lewis. 

Segments

Guest Introduction and Draft Win
Copied to clipboard!
(00:00:09)
  • Key Takeaway: David Sims of the Blank Check podcast joins The Big Picture to commemorate Daniel Day-Lewis’s career.
  • Summary: David Sims is introduced as a guest joining Sean Fennessey and Amanda Dobbins. The introduction briefly acknowledges Sims’s recent victory in a draft competition. The hosts confirm the main focus is building a ‘shrine’ for Daniel Day-Lewis.
2025 Film Slate Debate
Copied to clipboard!
(00:02:34)
  • Key Takeaway: The consensus among the hosts is that 2025 has been a ‘weird year’ for movies, feeling like a ‘flop fall’ for awards-bait films.
  • Summary: The panel debates the quality of 2025 films, noting that festival favorites like Sinners, Weapons, One Battle, and 28 Years Later are the few that have resonated strongly. They observe that many anticipated fall festival movies are not gaining momentum with typical Oscar voters. The conversation touches on the potential impact of major releases like Wicked and Avatar on the awards race.
Daniel Day-Lewis’s New Film
Copied to clipboard!
(00:14:44)
  • Key Takeaway: Daniel Day-Lewis’s new film, Anemone, co-written by him and directed by his son Ronan, is considered visually appealing but ultimately unsuccessful.
  • Summary: The film Anemone prompted Daniel Day-Lewis’s return to press after eight years of seclusion. The hosts found the movie abstract and poorly paced, noting that the plot explanation felt forced late in the runtime. They speculate that DDL’s participation was likely a personal project with his son rather than a return to major filmmaking.
Day-Lewis’s Retirement and Method
Copied to clipboard!
(00:18:35)
  • Key Takeaway: Daniel Day-Lewis reportedly retired due to hating the Oscar press cycle following Phantom Thread and has been actively trying to demythologize his Method acting approach during his recent press run.
  • Summary: DDL, who was 60 when he stepped away after Phantom Thread, expressed distaste for the attendant mythology and the subsequent awards campaigning. He has been more open about his process this year, possibly to counter the baggage of his legendary status. His career is characterized by intense immersion, contrasting with the more traditional, hard-drinking style of many classic British actors like Peter O’Toole.
Early Career and Filmography Start
Copied to clipboard!
(00:40:00)
  • Key Takeaway: Daniel Day-Lewis’s filmography begins with small, memorable roles in Sunday Bloody Sunday and a two-minute, racist thug scene in Gandhi (1982).
  • Summary: The panel begins cataloging DDL’s 22 feature films, noting that his early work includes a walk-on in Sunday Bloody Sunday. His first notable film appearance was as Colin, a racist thug insulting Mahatma Gandhi, a scene that remains highly affecting. The discussion then moves to The Bounty (1984), which featured strong performances from Hopkins and Gibson.
Merchant Ivory Style Debate
Copied to clipboard!
(00:48:27)
  • Key Takeaway: The film featuring Julian Sands was deemed DDL-esque but not a DDL-centric movie, leading to a ‘yellow’ rating.
  • Summary: The speakers debated a film where Daniel Day-Lewis plays a buttoned-up character, contrasting with the more flamboyant roles often associated with Julian Sands. The style was identified as early Merchant Ivory, romantic, and having more meaning than later, more restrained 90s Merchant Ivory films. The segment concluded with the decision to ‘yellow’ the film in the Hall of Fame consideration.
Early French Language Film
Copied to clipboard!
(00:51:05)
  • Key Takeaway: The 1986 French language drama Nanu (likely My Beautiful Laundrette or similar early work) is a rare example of a film written and directed by a woman in 1980s England that Daniel Day-Lewis appeared in.
  • Summary: The film, which Daniel Day-Lewis plays a cuckolded boyfriend in, was noted as being difficult to find on physical media. It was written and directed by Connie Templeman, a rare female director in 1980s England. The segment ultimately categorized this film as ‘red’ because it did not fit the established trajectory of his career.
The Unbearable Lightness of Being
Copied to clipboard!
(00:52:53)
  • Key Takeaway: The Unbearable Lightness of Being (1988) is considered a romantic drama adaptation that shed the postmodern literary complexity of Milan Kundera’s novel, and Daniel Day-Lewis’s role was somewhat anonymous.
  • Summary: Philip Kaufman’s film adaptation was seen as focusing only on the historical fiction/romantic drama aspects, losing the novel’s self-aware, postmodern edge. Day-Lewis’s character was described as a ‘heartthrob’ doctor who was unusually sex-forward compared to his later roles where he typically withholds his essence. The film was ultimately ‘yellowed’ despite its initial celebration.
Stars and Bars Comedy Failure
Copied to clipboard!
(00:59:41)
  • Key Takeaway: Stars and Bars (1988) is considered legitimately bad, with Daniel Day-Lewis being notably unfunny in the contemporary fish-out-of-water comedy role.
  • Summary: The film, directed by Pat O’Connor, featured an incredible cast of heavy hitters but was buried due to its poor quality. Day-Lewis’s performance was characterized by delivering lines with repetitive, overly intense righteousness, lacking the necessary comedic timing. This film is sandwiched critically between The Unbearable Lightness of Being and My Left Foot.
My Left Foot Oscar Triumph
Copied to clipboard!
(01:03:30)
  • Key Takeaway: My Left Foot (1989) is an Irish comedy disguised as a serious biopic, which served as Daniel Day-Lewis’s first Miramax Oscar triumph and established the ’transformer’ shorthand for his career.
  • Summary: The film is noted for being much funnier and more uplifting than Stars and Bars, despite its serious framework about Christy Brown’s struggle. Day-Lewis’s physical transformation, learning to use his foot for communication, became shorthand for his showy yet naturalistic acting style. This performance beat out strong competition, including Tom Cruise for Born on the Fourth of July.
Last of the Mohicans Action Star
Copied to clipboard!
(01:13:33)
  • Key Takeaway: The Last of the Mohicans (1992) marked Daniel Day-Lewis’s peak as a marquee idol and proved his capability as an action star through rigorous physical preparation.
  • Summary: This Michael Mann film represented a major transition for Day-Lewis away from buttoned-up or Irish roles into an American historical setting, where he learned survival skills like fire-building. The film was a massive commercial success, earning $150 million and cementing his status as a big star. The action sequences were deemed credible due to his commitment to the choreography.
Age of Innocence Masterpiece Status
Copied to clipboard!
(01:17:40)
  • Key Takeaway: The Age of Innocence (1993) arrived with underwhelming initial reception but has since achieved masterpiece status due to its powerful, wordless chemistry between Daniel Day-Lewis and Michelle Pfeiffer.
  • Summary: The film was a stylistic ‘zag’ for both Scorsese (following Goodfellas) and Day-Lewis (following the action of Last of the Mohicans), focusing on restraint. While Day-Lewis is central, the performance is not considered indispensable to the film’s success in the way some of his other roles are. The segment also noted that Rebecca Miller (Day-Lewis’s wife) directed a documentary praising this film.
In the Name of the Father Acclaim
Copied to clipboard!
(01:21:22)
  • Key Takeaway: In the Name of the Father (1993) is considered the best film about the Troubles by a Northern Irish observer and remains a highly satisfying, though sometimes overlooked, courtroom drama.
  • Summary: The film, based on Gerry Conlon’s wrongful conviction, was a huge critical success, earning multiple Oscar nominations. Day-Lewis plays a working-class Irish guy, a contrast to his more mythical roles, and his accent is highly credible. Its legacy might be slightly diminished because the 90s were saturated with urgent storytelling about the Troubles.
The Crucible as School Homework
Copied to clipboard!
(01:29:17)
  • Key Takeaway: The Crucible (1996) is categorized as a film destined for school curricula rather than enduring cinematic greatness, despite Arthur Miller receiving an Oscar nomination for the screenplay.
  • Summary: The film is seen as a profound allegorical text but not a great movie adaptation, with Day-Lewis delivering passionate but overly righteous intensity. The director, Nicholas Hytner, is also known for Center Stage and The Madness of King George. The segment noted that Day-Lewis met his future wife, Rebecca Miller, around the time of this production.
The Boxer Retirement Attempt
Copied to clipboard!
(01:35:49)
  • Key Takeaway: The Boxer (1997) was Daniel Day-Lewis’s third and final collaboration with Jim Sheridan, marking his first announced retirement where he learned to box for the role.
  • Summary: The film inverts In the Name of the Father by focusing on an ex-IRA volunteer trying to stay out of conflict, exploring internal IRA splinter warfare. While engaging, it is considered lesser than In the Name of the Father, and listeners felt the audience might have been experiencing ‘Day-Lewis fatigue’ by this point. Emily Watson’s performance was praised as lovely, coming right after Breaking the Waves.
Bill the Butcher Voice Analysis
Copied to clipboard!
(01:38:44)
  • Key Takeaway: Daniel Day-Lewis’s voice for Bill the Butcher in Gangs of New York is an over-enunciated American accent, distinct from his usual British roles.
  • Summary: The voice Daniel Day-Lewis uses for Bill the Butcher is identified as a unique, over-enunciated American accent, unlike his typical British character voices. This distinctive voice caused surprise among audiences upon the film’s release. The performance is highly defended as one of the greatest in Scorsese’s filmography.
Gangs of New York Production Context
Copied to clipboard!
(01:39:12)
  • Key Takeaway: The script for Gangs of New York underwent numerous passes over many years, and Leonardo DiCaprio’s desire to work with Scorsese was crucial for the film’s realization.
  • Summary: The film’s script evolved significantly, with an early 1982 version by Jay Cox being considered a masterpiece. The movie’s massive scale necessitated an enormous budget, and it was ultimately made because Leonardo DiCaprio actively sought a collaboration with Martin Scorsese. DiCaprio is credited with using his influence to greenlight the project.
Oscar Race Context 2003
Copied to clipboard!
(01:42:13)
  • Key Takeaway: The 2003 Best Actor Oscar race featured four previous winners (Nicholson, Cage, Day-Lewis, Caine) against Adrian Brody, who ultimately won for The Pianist.
  • Summary: Daniel Day-Lewis was the favorite to win the Oscar for Gangs of New York, but Adrian Brody won for The Pianist. The competition included established veterans like Jack Nicholson (About Schmidt), Nicolas Cage (Adaptation), and Michael Caine (The Quiet American). Brody’s win was notable as he was the only nominee who had not previously won an Academy Award.
The Ballad of Jack and Rose
Copied to clipboard!
(01:43:14)
  • Key Takeaway: Daniel Day-Lewis’s 2005 film The Ballad of Jack and Rose, directed by his wife Rebecca Miller, features him playing an off-the-grid character similar to his later role in Anemone.
  • Summary: Following Gangs of New York, Day-Lewis starred in The Ballad of Jack and Rose, a small drama written and directed by his wife, Rebecca Miller. The film features a reverse Oedipus/Electra dynamic and was not widely acclaimed, though one host enjoyed it. This marks the first of two collaborations where Day-Lewis plays an isolated, off-the-grid figure.
There Will Be Blood Analysis
Copied to clipboard!
(01:46:10)
  • Key Takeaway: There Will Be Blood (2007) is considered Paul Thomas Anderson’s opus and features one of the most iconic 21st-century acting performances in Daniel Plainview.
  • Summary: The film is instantly canonical and represents a major career peak for PTA, solidifying his status as a great American director. Daniel Plainview’s performance is frequently cited in discussions about the best acting of the century, characterized by intense, spiraling descent. The film is noted for its capital ‘T’ themes about America but is light on female characters.
Nine Musical Adaptation Critique
Copied to clipboard!
(01:50:14)
  • Key Takeaway: Rob Marshall’s film adaptation of the musical Nine (2009) is criticized for cheap-looking artificiality and poor choreography direction, despite Day-Lewis’s involvement.
  • Summary: The film Nine is a musical adaptation of 8 1/2, and Daniel Day-Lewis was a late addition after Javier Bardem dropped out. The direction by Rob Marshall is faulted for lacking visual dynamism, especially compared to the source material and Marshall’s previous work on Chicago. The film’s visual execution is described as looking ‘junky’ and cheap.
Lincoln’s Critical Acclaim and Style
Copied to clipboard!
(01:54:47)
  • Key Takeaway: Lincoln (2012) is a highly regarded film that showcases the ‘dirty work of government’ rather than just Lincoln’s inherent greatness, and Day-Lewis won his third Oscar for it.
  • Summary: The film is praised for depicting the political maneuvering required to pass the 13th Amendment, contrasting with simple folky anecdotes. Day-Lewis reportedly researched extensively, including visiting the Library of Congress to hear recordings of Lincoln’s voice. The film was a major success, securing Spielberg’s first acting Oscar win.
Phantom Thread as Comedy
Copied to clipboard!
(02:01:21)
  • Key Takeaway: Phantom Thread (2017) is surprisingly hilarious, with Daniel Day-Lewis delivering a funny performance by playing an uptight British couturier, despite the film’s weighty themes.
  • Summary: The film is described as a wonderful and funny movie about marriage, immediately establishing its comedic tone within the first two minutes for the hosts. Leslie Manville’s performance as the mother figure is highlighted as central to the humor. Despite the comedy, the film still contains weighty themes concerning the character’s self-immolation and illness.
Finalizing the Hall of Fame
Copied to clipboard!
(02:04:37)
  • Key Takeaway: The final Hall of Fame selection process confirmed eight ‘greenlit’ films, leaving The Unbearable Lightness of Being as the preferred choice among the remaining ‘yellow’ contenders.
  • Summary: Eight films were confirmed as guaranteed entries, including The Last of the Mohicans, There Will Be Blood, and Lincoln. The remaining four contenders were My Beautiful Laundrette, A Room with a View, The Unbearable Lightness of Being, and The Boxer. The Boxer was eliminated due to the inclusion of another Jim Sheridan film, and The Unbearable Lightness of Being was chosen over A Room with a View.