The Growing Experiment Of Putting Solar Panels On Farmland

Key Takeaways Copied to clipboard!

• Agrivoltaics, the practice of co-locating agriculture and solar power generation, offers dual benefits such as crop cooling/shade and increased solar panel efficiency, though its success varies significantly based on climate and crop type.  Copied to clipboard!
• For large-scale commodity crops, agrivoltaics faces significant hurdles including the high cost of raising panels high enough for machinery and the negative impact of shade on sun-loving crops, though future climate conditions might increase the benefit of shade.  Copied to clipboard!
• Community opposition to solar panels on farmland, driven by aesthetic concerns and loss of agricultural identity, can be mitigated if solar developers collaborate with local communities to ensure shared economic benefits.  Copied to clipboard!

Segments Expand All Collapse All

Introduction to Agrivoltaics Concept

Copied to clipboard!

(00:00:52)

• Key Takeaway: Agrivoltaics combines agriculture and solar power generation on the same land to achieve environmental and economic sustainability.
• Summary: Agrivoltaics is an experiment where farmers grow crops underneath solar panels. This dual harvest benefits the system because the panels provide shade, and plant evaporation cools the panels, increasing their efficiency. Farmers can potentially gain two harvests: traditional crops and solar energy revenue.

Defining Agrivoltaics Terminology

Copied to clipboard!

(00:01:45)

• Key Takeaway: The term ‘agrivoltaics’ is a portmanteau of ‘agriculture’ and ‘photovoltaic’ describing simultaneous farming and solar energy generation.
• Summary: The word agrivoltaics combines agriculture and photovoltaic (PV panel). Farmers generate income from both the crop harvest and the solar energy harvest. Farmers may lease land to solar developers for rental payments or install ground-mounted arrays to power their own operations.

Shade Benefits for Specialty Crops

Copied to clipboard!

(00:03:02)

• Key Takeaway: Shade from solar panels can benefit certain crops, herbs, and produce, contrary to the assumption that all plants require full sun.
• Summary: Research in hotter climates like Arizona and farmer experience in Missouri show that shade benefits some crops. This shade helps mitigate the effects of intense summer heat, which can cause wilting and force farmers to harvest extremely early.

Sheep Grazing as Solar Site Management

Copied to clipboard!

(00:03:51)

• Key Takeaway: Sheep grazing is currently the most common and successful form of agrivoltaics due to their appropriate height and non-destructive grazing habits.
• Summary: Sheep grazing is cited as the biggest agrivoltaics success story because sheep are the right height to graze under panels. They eat the grass growing within the array, unlike goats, which might chew wires or jump on panels. This offers a simple ‘plug-and-play’ land management solution for solar developers.

Farmer Incentives for Adoption

Copied to clipboard!

(00:04:31)

• Key Takeaway: Farmers are incentivized to engage in agrivoltaics by collaborating on land management for solar arrays and utilizing shade for heat-sensitive produce.
• Summary: One major incentive is collaboration, as solar operators need land management, and farmers are uniquely qualified to provide it. Another key driver is shade, which helps farmers like Linda Hetzel grow herbs and produce in increasingly intense summer heat. Shade benefits both the human workers and the quality of the harvested produce.

Solar Industry Motivation for Agrivoltaics

Copied to clipboard!

(00:06:08)

• Key Takeaway: Solar developers seek agrivoltaics to reduce community pushback caused by land competition and to improve project acceptance in agricultural areas.
• Summary: Solar projects require large, flat, sunny land, creating competition with agriculture. Developers are interested in agrivoltaics to make projects better suited for and more accepted by rural communities. Successful integration can ease project approval delays and reduce development costs.

Challenges for Cattle Integration

Copied to clipboard!

(00:07:00)

• Key Takeaway: Integrating cattle into solar farms is challenging due to the need for significantly taller panel infrastructure, increasing costs and unknown interactions with equipment.
• Summary: Cattle require much taller solar panel designs than sheep, which exponentially increases steel and foundation costs. Researchers are interested in whether shade could benefit dairy cows by reducing heat stress and subsequent negative impacts on milk production. The interaction between cattle and the infrastructure remains largely unknown.

Scaling Agrivoltaics for Commodity Crops

Copied to clipboard!

(00:10:38)

• Key Takeaway: Scaling agrivoltaics to commodity crops like corn and wheat requires overcoming cost barriers related to panel height and spacing needed for conventional farm equipment.
• Summary: Commodity crops, which cover most U.S. cropland, present challenges because panels must be raised from the typical four feet to six, eight, or twelve feet. This height increase drives up costs due to greater steel requirements and deeper foundations. Furthermore, spacing between rows must increase from 18 feet to about 40 feet to accommodate machinery, reducing the overall energy yield per field.

Economic Trade-offs and Future Climate

Copied to clipboard!

(00:15:28)

• Key Takeaway: While current commodity crop studies show yield reduction, future climate variability, including extreme heat, may make the protective benefits of panels economically advantageous.
• Summary: Current models focus on fitting agriculture into existing solar farm designs, rather than optimizing for co-location. As the climate changes toward more extreme heat days, the protective function of panels against heat stress could become highly beneficial. Farmers might benefit financially even with slight yield reductions if the income from solar energy is significantly higher and less risky than traditional farming.

Addressing Community Opposition

Copied to clipboard!

(00:16:17)

• Key Takeaway: Solar industry opposition stems from aesthetic concerns and a sense of place, which can be eased by ensuring local communities benefit financially from energy revenue.
• Summary: Many counties are enacting bans or restrictions on converting cropland to solar farming due to aesthetic concerns and the perceived loss of agricultural identity. Solar developers can ease tensions by co-developing models that feed revenue back into the local community for improvements like schools. This addresses the perception that costs are borne locally while benefits accrue to distant energy consumers.

Future Research Directions

Copied to clipboard!

(00:22:26)

• Key Takeaway: Optimizing agrivoltaics requires research into ideal configurations and the potential use of smaller, AI-driven robotic equipment to maximize co-location benefits.
• Summary: Future research must focus on optimizing the configuration of panels (height, spacing, tilt) to meet multiple needs simultaneously. The development of smaller equipment, potentially including AI-driven robots, could allow for productive farming in narrower spaces between rows. Innovation remains the cornerstone for increasing farm productivity through new approaches like agrivoltaics.