Smosh Reads Reddit Stories

Reddit Stories That Make Us Crash Out | Reading Reddit Stories

November 1, 2025

Key Takeaways Copied to clipboard!

  • The hosts of Smosh Reads Reddit Stories are reading relationship-focused stories from Reddit under the theme "Am I Overreacting?" 
  • The first Tinder date story revealed extreme red flags when the man sent aggressive, entitled texts after being denied entry to the woman's house, escalating from sweet to hostile within an hour. 
  • The second story confirmed that the boyfriend intentionally bought the dress the girlfriend wanted for his mother to "humble" the girlfriend for being "overly excited" about a trivial item, leading the girlfriend to leave him. 
  • The core story involves a guest being publicly uninvited from a wedding breakfast by the bride, leading to extreme humiliation for the guest and subsequent disappointment in her boyfriend, Eric, for not defending her. 
  • The situation was complicated by the revelation that the Maid of Honor was Eric's ex-girlfriend who had cheated on him, suggesting potential malice behind the invitation error. 
  • Despite the severity of the incident and Eric's passive reaction, the original poster chose not to break up with Eric, viewing his behavior as 'hopeless' rather than malicious, though it remains a 'big dark mark' on their relationship record. 

Segments

Tinder Date Creepiness
Copied to clipboard!
(00:01:00)
  • Key Takeaway: A first-date escalation involving pushiness to enter the woman’s home and subsequent aggressive, drunk texts at 3 AM are major red flags.
  • Summary: The Tinder date escalated when the man insisted on coming inside after the first date, which the woman refused. Later that night, he sent texts ranging from wanting to spend the night to calling her names for not letting him in. The man later apologized, blaming alcohol, but the consensus was that his immediate shift in demeanor indicated controlling behavior.
Boyfriend Gifts Dress to Mom
Copied to clipboard!
(00:13:35)
  • Key Takeaway: A boyfriend bought a $200 dress his girlfriend frequently mentioned wanting for his mother, gifting the girlfriend only a $50 Sephora gift card for her birthday.
  • Summary: The boyfriend bought the expensive dress the girlfriend loved and gave it to his mother a month before the girlfriend’s birthday. When confronted later, the boyfriend admitted he did it intentionally to “humble” her because he felt she was “overly excited” about something trivial like a dress. The girlfriend immediately left and planned to stay with her mother.
Shower Pooping Revelation
Copied to clipboard!
(00:26:28)
  • Key Takeaway: A girlfriend revealed she habitually defecates in the shower and uses her toe to push the feces down the drain, claiming comfort in the relationship.
  • Summary: After getting drunk, the girlfriend pooped in the shower and used her toe to push the feces into the drain, which she admitted she does regularly. She justified this behavior by saying she feels comfortable enough not to hide who she is anymore. The OP immediately lost attraction and decided to break up with her.
Boyfriend’s Roommate Demands
Copied to clipboard!
(00:38:11)
  • Key Takeaway: A boyfriend, renting a room from his roommate, aggressively demanded the roommate stop cleaning up his messes and then later demanded the roommate wash his dishes after two days of neglect.
  • Summary: Initially, the boyfriend complained when the roommate washed his dishes or touched his trash, setting a boundary against touching his things. Later, the boyfriend demanded the roommate wash his dishes if they sat in the sink for two days, despite the roommate owning the house. The roommate, who is shy, apologized profusely and cleaned the dishes, leading the OP to view her boyfriend as an entitled bully.
Uninvited From Wedding
Copied to clipboard!
(00:50:47)
  • Key Takeaway: A guest was publicly uninvited from the wedding breakfast portion of an event after traveling several hours and spending significant money, despite the invitation explicitly including the meal.
  • Summary: The OP and her partner were invited to the full wedding, including the breakfast, incurring substantial travel and accommodation costs. Upon arrival, the bride informed the OP publicly that she was only invited to the service and reception, not the meal. The OP felt humiliated and left in the rain, while her partner remained silent to avoid a scene.
Wedding Guest Ejection Details
Copied to clipboard!
(00:52:31)
  • Key Takeaway: The guest was explicitly told by the bride that her invitation only covered the service and reception, excluding the 140-person wedding breakfast.
  • Summary: The guest arrived at the reception venue, found no place setting, and was informed by the bride that she was not invited to the breakfast, only the service and reception. This occurred publicly in front of seated guests, forcing the guest to leave in the rain to walk 20 minutes to a suggested pub. The other guests at the pub were only invited to the evening reception, confirming the OP was uniquely excluded from the middle portion of the event.
Hosts React to Eric’s Inaction
Copied to clipboard!
(00:56:16)
  • Key Takeaway: The hosts strongly condemned Eric for staying quiet and not leaving the breakfast with the guest, viewing his inaction as a major failure in support.
  • Summary: The hosts reacted strongly to the story, calling the bride’s actions tacky and unacceptable, especially since the invitation implied full attendance. They emphasized that Eric should have stood up for his partner or left with her immediately, citing safety concerns given the rural location and bad weather. The consensus among the hosts and initial Reddit comments was that Eric’s behavior was a significant red flag.
Initial Update and Context Clarification
Copied to clipboard!
(01:03:00)
  • Key Takeaway: The OP confirmed Eric stayed at the party, but she felt validated by the community response, leading her to postpone any breakup decision.
  • Summary: The original poster felt better after reading supportive comments, noting that Eric was still at the party and she planned to discuss the situation when he returned. She clarified that UK wedding etiquette often separates guests between the afternoon ‘wedding breakfast’ and the evening reception, but excluding a named plus-one from the breakfast is a serious breach of etiquette.
Crucial Detail: The Ex-Girlfriend
Copied to clipboard!
(01:06:23)
  • Key Takeaway: A major detail emerged: the Maid of Honor, Helen, was Eric’s ex-girlfriend who had cheated on him, suggesting a coordinated effort to exclude the OP.
  • Summary: The OP revealed that the Maid of Honor, Helen, was Eric’s ex who dumped him after cheating, and Marie (the bride) failed to mention Helen’s prominent role. This context suggested the seating error might not have been accidental, as Helen seemed pleased by the OP’s removal. Eric was upset about being let down by his friend Marie, but the OP felt he failed to prioritize her distress over his own feelings of insult.
Eric’s Post-Event Behavior
Copied to clipboard!
(01:07:43)
  • Key Takeaway: Eric returned home very early, focused primarily on how he was insulted by the bride, and failed to offer a proper apology or acknowledge the OP’s humiliation.
  • Summary: Eric returned home at 8 a.m. still in his suit, explaining he froze up but later focused on his disappointment with Marie and Helen, not the OP’s experience. The OP noted that while Eric had a bad time, he was warm and fed, unlike her, leading her to feel he didn’t fully grasp the severity of her ordeal. Despite this, she decided not to break up with him immediately, hoping to move past the incident.