Behind the Bastards

How The FBI Botched the 2001 Anthrax Scare (Part 1)

October 2, 2025

Key Takeaways Copied to clipboard!

  • The episode introduces Steven Hatfill as the subject of this part of the *Behind the Bastards* series, detailing his complex and often exaggerated background which made him a plausible suspect for the 2001 anthrax attacks. 
  • Hatfill's early life is marked by a pattern of grand claims and inconsistencies, including his service in the Green Berets and his involvement with the Rhodesian military and its controversial chemical and biological weapons program. 
  • Hatfill's career trajectory led him to become a recognized expert in biodefense, culminating in a fellowship at USAMRIID and consulting work with private contractors, but his professional ascent was marred by the CIA and DoD denying him security clearances due to trustworthiness concerns shortly before 9/11. 
  • Concerns about Steven Hatfill's background and potential lies led to recommendations that he should not hold a security clearance, jeopardizing his employment at SAIC and USAMRIT just before 9/11. 
  • Prior to 9/11, Hatfill was contracted by the U.S. government to design a fake mobile biowarfare production laboratory to train troops for potential conflict in Iraq, highlighting a dark irony given the later anthrax attacks. 
  • The fact that Hatfill designed a mobile lab and possessed the expertise to create weaponized anthrax made him an immediate person of interest when the 2001 anthrax attacks occurred, setting the stage for the events discussed in the next part of the *Behind the Bastards* episode, "How The FBI Botched the 2001 Anthrax Scare (Part 1)". 

Segments

Introduction to Anthrax Scare
Copied to clipboard!
(00:00:05)
  • Key Takeaway: The Behind the Bastards episode on the 2001 anthrax attacks will focus on how the FBI and media wrongly accused individuals, specifically centering on Steven Hatfill.
  • Summary: The episode follows up on previous discussions about misidentified terrorism suspects by focusing on the 2001 anthrax attacks that killed five people shortly after 9/11. The attacks involved letters containing white powder sent to various recipients, including government figures. The central figure for this two-part series is Steven Hatfill, who is described as a fascinating person whose life story made him a prime, though ultimately innocent, suspect.
Hatfill’s Early Life and Military Aspiration
Copied to clipboard!
(00:04:44)
  • Key Takeaway: Steven Hatfill’s early life included solo glider piloting at age 14 and an intense desire to become a Marine Corps fighter pilot, a goal thwarted by imperfect vision.
  • Summary: Born in 1953, Hatfill showed early interest in medical science and military history, despite being a poor student otherwise. After high school, he attended Southwestern College and aimed to be a jet pilot through an ROTC-like program. When the Marines disqualified him from flying jets due to vision issues, this failure reportedly ‘shattered’ him.
Congo Medical Volunteering
Copied to clipboard!
(00:08:04)
  • Key Takeaway: Following his military setback, the 19-year-old Hatfill traveled uninvited to the Congo to volunteer at a mission hospital, where he gained basic hematology and parasitology experience.
  • Summary: Hatfill suspended his college education and traveled to the Congo to volunteer at a mission hospital run by Glenn and Lena Estruth. Though lacking formal training, he learned basic medical skills, confirming his interest in medical science. This move demonstrated significant personal initiative and boldness, as he traveled to a dangerous location without prior arrangement.
Military Service Discrepancies
Copied to clipboard!
(00:10:03)
  • Key Takeaway: Hatfill repeatedly claimed to have joined the elite Green Berets, but military records indicate he only briefly entered the Special Forces qualification course before being discharged from active duty into the Army National Guard.
  • Summary: After finishing his undergraduate degree in 1975, Hatfill joined the Army and claimed direct enlistment into the Green Berets, including parachute school and radio operator training. However, reporting shows he failed to complete the rigorous Special Forces qualification course after only a few weeks. This rapid shift from active duty special forces training to the National Guard suggests a significant failure or issue during his qualification period.
First Marriage and Divorce Fallout
Copied to clipboard!
(00:13:29)
  • Key Takeaway: Hatfill married Carolyn Estruth, the teenage daughter of the missionary couple he worked with in the Congo, but the marriage quickly dissolved after her father was executed by mercenaries in Zaire in 1977, leading to divorce and Hatfill abandoning contact with his daughter.
  • Summary: Hatfill married Carolyn Estruth in 1976; her father, Glenn Estruth, was executed by mercenaries in Zaire in 1977. Following the death, the marriage soured, and Hatfill divorced Carolyn in 1978, subsequently having no contact with their daughter, Cayman, for many years. This period marks a significant personal rupture before his next major move abroad.
Move to Rhodesia and Medical School
Copied to clipboard!
(00:15:41)
  • Key Takeaway: Immediately after his divorce, Hatfill moved to Rhodesia in 1978, a white supremacist pariah state, to attend medical school, a choice deemed morally questionable given the country’s brutal bush war.
  • Summary: In 1978, Hatfill relocated to Rhodesia, which was internationally blacklisted for its racist governance, to attend the Godfrey Huggins School of Medicine. During this time, Rhodesia was actively engaged in a bush war and was known to use chemical and biological weapons against insurgents. Hatfill later claimed to have volunteered as a medic attached to the elite, idolized, and racist Selous Scouts unit.
Rhodesian Anthrax Outbreak Context
Copied to clipboard!
(00:27:00)
  • Key Takeaway: Hatfill’s time in Rhodesia (1978-1980) coincided with a massive, likely natural, anthrax epidemic that killed thousands of cattle and hundreds of people, which later became a point of suspicion due to Rhodesia’s known CBW program.
  • Summary: While Hatfill was in Rhodesia, the country experienced a major anthrax outbreak, killing thousands of cattle and hundreds of people. Although Rhodesia had a confirmed history of using biological weapons, including anthrax, experts suggest this specific outbreak was more likely a natural epidemic due to the suspension of state veterinary programs during the war. However, this coincidence later fueled suspicion against Hatfill.
Medical Education and Resume Inflation
Copied to clipboard!
(00:36:16)
  • Key Takeaway: Hatfill eventually earned his medical degree in 1984 after repeating a year of medical school, but he continued to inflate his credentials by falsely claiming a PhD from Rhodes University and affiliation with non-existent UK medical bodies.
  • Summary: Hatfill graduated in 1984 after studying in South Africa, though he reportedly had a temper tantrum and punched a peer when failing a year. He later claimed degrees from the UK, including a non-existent Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons, Edinburgh, and falsely claimed a PhD from Rhodes University after his dissertation was rejected in 1995. This pattern shows a consistent tendency to exaggerate his qualifications for professional advancement.
Biodefense Career and USAMRIID
Copied to clipboard!
(00:42:25)
  • Key Takeaway: Hatfill secured a fellowship at USAMRIID, the top U.S. biodefense lab at Fort Detrick, where he specialized in viruses and trained special forces on defensive techniques against biological agents.
  • Summary: After a fellowship at Oxford, Hatfill began working for the National Institutes of Health and then joined USAMRIID in 1997 to study Ebola and hemorrhagic fevers. This facility researches defenses against weaponized pathogens, including anthrax, though Hatfill primarily focused on viruses. He became known for teaching special forces teams defensive protocols against biological attacks.
Controversial Public Statements
Copied to clipboard!
(00:50:58)
  • Key Takeaway: Hatfill alarmed emergency preparedness officials by giving overly specific public presentations detailing exactly how a terrorist could use a wheelchair to smuggle a biological agent past White House security.
  • Summary: In public seminars, Hatfill provided detailed scenarios on circumventing White House security with biological agents, alarming officials like New York City’s emergency preparedness director, Jerome Hauer. Despite warnings that his details were too specific, Hatfill dismissed the concerns, suggesting a pattern of irresponsible disclosure regarding sensitive security vulnerabilities.
Mentorship by Bill Patrick
Copied to clipboard!
(00:52:59)
  • Key Takeaway: Hatfill developed a close, father-son relationship with retired bioweapons expert Bill Patrick, who possessed secret patents on weaponized anthrax and mentored Hatfill, potentially transferring specialized knowledge.
  • Summary: Bill Patrick, a top expert with secret patents on weaponized anthrax, mentored Hatfill, viewing him as a suitable protégé. Patrick recommended Hatfill for consulting work and shared classified briefings on weaponization processes, even keeping lab equipment capable of creating fine powder in his home. This relationship provided Hatfill with access to knowledge that exceeded his official credentials.
Security Clearance Denial
Copied to clipboard!
(00:57:36)
  • Key Takeaway: In 2001, the CIA denied Hatfill a top-secret security clearance, and subsequently, the Department of Defense suspended his clearance, effectively jeopardizing his career in sensitive defense work.
  • Summary: Hatfill’s application for a top-secret clearance at the CIA was denied after a polygraph test, with the agency stating he could not be trusted. The Department of Defense followed suit by suspending his clearance shortly thereafter. This denial, occurring just before 9/11, severely impacted his employment at SAIC and USAMRID, as his work required access to sensitive information.
Security Clearance Jeopardy
Copied to clipboard!
(00:58:58)
  • Key Takeaway: Findings regarding Steven Hatfill’s background potentially led to recommendations against granting him any security clearance by federal agencies.
  • Summary: If authorities determined Hatfill had lied about his background, they concluded he could not work with them, leading to the revocation of his security clearance. This action immediately endangered his job at SAIC and his work with USAMRIT, threatening his entire career in 2001.
Designing Fake Biowarfare Lab
Copied to clipboard!
(00:59:23)
  • Key Takeaway: Before 9/11, Hatfill was tasked by the military to design a mobile biowarfare production laboratory for training purposes against suspected Iraqi WMD capabilities.
  • Summary: One of Hatfill’s final projects at SAIC involved designing a fake mobile biowarfare lab, anticipating potential U.S. troop deployment in the Middle East against a leader suspected of possessing WMDs. The U.S. government paid Hatfill to create a facility Saddam Hussein was not known to possess, which was built into an 18-wheeler trailer using old lab equipment.
Anthrax Attack Implications
Copied to clipboard!
(01:01:05)
  • Key Takeaway: Hatfill’s prior work designing and building a mobile bioweapons lab made him a prime suspect after the anthrax attacks suggested military-grade production methods were used.
  • Summary: Although the mobile lab was never operational, the realization that the anthrax attacks likely originated from military stockpiles or utilized similar weaponization techniques immediately drew scrutiny to Hatfill. His expertise in building such a facility and knowing how to make weaponized anthrax placed him directly on the list of potential suspects.
Transition to 9/11 and Aftermath
Copied to clipboard!
(01:01:37)
  • Key Takeaway: The narrative of How The FBI Botched the 2001 Anthrax Scare (Part 1) concludes with the events of 9/11, setting up how the subsequent anthrax attacks dramatically altered Steven Hatfill’s life.
  • Summary: The episode ends at the point where 9/11 has occurred, immediately preceding the anthrax attacks. These attacks are established as the catalyst that would place Hatfill in the crosshairs of federal law enforcement and the media.