Why Americans don't want to move for jobs anymore

Key Takeaways Copied to clipboard!

• Americans are moving for jobs at about half the rate they were 30 years ago, leading to what the episode calls the 'homebody economy.'  Copied to clipboard!
• The decline in mobility is attributed to factors like increased industry/education clustering, political sorting, and the 'two-body problem' arising from more dual-earner households as the gender pay gap narrows.  Copied to clipboard!
• Despite the overall trend, specific locations like Huntsville, Alabama, continue to attract federal and defense jobs, though relocation rates for those moves remain low due to personal constraints and regional differences in quality of life/cost of living.  Copied to clipboard!

Segments Expand All Collapse All

Jobs Report Disruption

Copied to clipboard!

(00:00:25)

• Key Takeaway: The federal government shutdown prevented the release of the official Bureau of Labor Statistics jobs report.
• Summary: The episode opens on an unusual Jobs Friday because a government shutdown halted the release of the official jobs report. Alternative data from ADP and Revellio Labs suggested weak job growth, estimating the BLS number would have been around 38,000 jobs. State-level data showed significant divergence, with California gaining 25,000 jobs while Texas lost 10,000.

Record Low Mobility Rates

Copied to clipboard!

(00:01:41)

• Key Takeaway: Americans are moving across state lines for work at half the rate seen 30 years ago.
• Summary: Despite regional job booms and busts, Americans are staying put, leading to the ’era of home bodies.’ This low mobility rate is a significant shift from the traditional American narrative of moving for opportunity. The episode sets out to explore the reasons behind this record low movement.

Huntsville Relocation Challenges

Copied to clipboard!

(00:02:55)

• Key Takeaway: Federal agency relocations to Huntsville, Alabama, faced significant resistance from employees concerned about social factors and personal ties.
• Summary: Huntsville, a federal workforce mecca for defense and space, saw low relocation rates when agencies like the FBI moved staff from D.C., with only about 10% of one division moving. Concerns included Alabama’s history regarding race and immovable personal obligations like shared custody or elder care. Similar worries about staff retention were noted for the planned move of Space Command from Colorado Springs.

Reasons for Staying Put

Copied to clipboard!

(00:05:26)

• Key Takeaway: The decline in job-related migration is linked to increased professional clustering, political alignment, and the complexity of dual-earner households.
• Summary: Economist Urvi Kantan identified that workers increasingly stick to areas based on industry and education, such as tech workers in the Bay Area. Political sorting also plays a role, with over 40% of Americans citing politics as an influence on where they live. Furthermore, as more women work, the ’two-body problem’ makes moving for one spouse’s career much harder.

Closing Pay Gap Impact

Copied to clipboard!

(00:07:28)

• Key Takeaway: The narrowing gender pay gap contributes to lower mobility because couples with more similar salaries find it harder to prioritize one career over the other during a move.
• Summary: While the median wage for women is still about 85% of men’s (up from 75% in the 90s), this parity makes prioritizing one career during a relocation difficult. When both partners earn similar salaries, staying put becomes an easier default decision. Additionally, regional wage variation has shrunk, reducing the financial incentive to move for better pay.

Remote Work and Huntsville Appeal

Copied to clipboard!

(00:08:46)

• Key Takeaway: Remote work allows employees to take new jobs without relocating, while Huntsville’s affordability remains a key draw for those who do move.
• Summary: Flexible work arrangements mean employees can accept new positions while remaining in their current location. For those who do move, like the FBI worker Sharonda Ware, factors like Huntsville’s lower housing costs (30% less than Colorado Springs) and perceived community friendliness can outweigh initial concerns.