Why are so many public schools closing?

Key Takeaways Copied to clipboard!

• Declining enrollment in public schools, driven by falling birth rates and a challenging housing market, is forcing districts to consider closures, impacting community resources and student learning.  Copied to clipboard!
• School closures are often a symptom of a larger economic issue where reduced per-pupil funding, due to fewer students, makes it difficult for schools to maintain essential services and programs, creating a downward spiral.  Copied to clipboard!
• Parents are actively fighting to keep their neighborhood public schools open, viewing their choice to attend these schools as a valid form of school choice that deserves preservation.  Copied to clipboard!

Segments Expand All Collapse All

Parent’s School Search

Copied to clipboard!

(00:00:15)

• Key Takeaway: Parents meticulously research public schools based on performance data, particularly for minority students, to find suitable educational environments for their children.
• Summary: Taylor Iogo relocated to Atlanta and prioritized finding a home near a public school with strong performance metrics, especially for Black children. She found West Manor Elementary School, which she describes as a nurturing environment where staff and families are closely connected.

Threat of School Closures

Copied to clipboard!

(00:01:01)

• Key Takeaway: Public schools like West Manor Elementary are facing potential closure due to declining enrollment, a trend impacting districts across the country.
• Summary: A rumor at a kindergarten graduation revealed that West Manor Elementary might close as part of Atlanta Public Schools’ strategy to address declining enrollment. This issue is not isolated to Atlanta, with districts in Minnesota, Tennessee, and Texas also grappling with similar challenges.

Expert on School Closures

Copied to clipboard!

(00:03:02)

• Key Takeaway: School closure consultants, like Tracy Richter, often face angry parents as they help districts manage underutilized facilities due to declining student populations.
• Summary: Tracy Richter, a Vice President of Planning Services for HPM, specializes in construction management for K-12 education, including advising districts on closing schools with insufficient enrollment. He acknowledges that a significant part of his work involves addressing the concerns of enraged parents during these difficult transitions.

Causes of Enrollment Decline

Copied to clipboard!

(00:04:10)

• Key Takeaway: Falling birth rates and a lack of affordable housing, exacerbated by mortgage lock-in, are the primary drivers of declining public school enrollment nationwide.
• Summary: The birth rate in the U.S. has dropped significantly since 2007, contributing to fewer students. Additionally, the high cost of housing in metro areas and homeowners being reluctant to sell due to unfavorable mortgage rates prevent families from moving into areas with school-age children.

Economic Impact on Schools

Copied to clipboard!

(00:05:34)

• Key Takeaway: Decreased student enrollment directly translates to reduced funding for public schools, jeopardizing their ability to offer essential services and programs.
• Summary: Public schools rely on per-pupil enrollment for state and federal funding, so fewer students mean less money. This financial strain makes it difficult to afford necessities like nurses, specialized teachers, and advanced courses, potentially leading to a cycle of program cuts and further enrollment decline.

Consequences of Closures

Copied to clipboard!

(00:07:10)

• Key Takeaway: School closures can negatively impact students’ academic performance and disrupt their social connections, while emergency federal funding has temporarily masked the severity of the issue for some districts.
• Summary: Research indicates that school closures can have detrimental effects on students’ learning and well-being. The pandemic’s influx of federal funds provided a temporary reprieve, but this aid has been depleted, bringing the underlying enrollment challenges back to the forefront.

Parental Advocacy

Copied to clipboard!

(00:08:20)

• Key Takeaway: Parents are actively campaigning to keep their neighborhood public schools open, emphasizing that choosing a local public school is a deliberate choice that should be supported.
• Summary: Taylor Iyogo and other parents in Atlanta Public Schools are organizing to save West Manor Elementary, highlighting their commitment to their local public school. They are using social media, lawn signs, and community meetings to advocate for their schools, arguing that loyal families shouldn’t be penalized with closures.