What Susan Collins Wants to See Before Supporting Another Rate Cut

Key Takeaways Copied to clipboard!

• Boston Fed President Susan Collins emphasizes balancing concerns over stubbornly elevated inflation (currently at 2.9% for Core PCE) against potential labor market deterioration, noting that recent rate cuts have positioned the Fed appropriately for now.  Copied to clipboard!
• Collins views tariffs as intertwined with uncertainty, suggesting their inflationary impact is a 'long one-off' that could take months or longer to fully materialize, while also noting businesses are finding unexpected pricing power.  Copied to clipboard!
• The discussion highlights the Federal Reserve's current policy ambiguity, driven by conflicting signals in the labor market (softening demand but no significant unemployment rise) and persistent inflation, further complicated by data blackouts and evolving general-purpose technologies like AI.  Copied to clipboard!

Segments Expand All Collapse All

Boston Fed Conference Context

Copied to clipboard!

(00:02:23)

• Key Takeaway: The Boston Fed’s 69th economic conference theme is the U.S. economy in a changing global landscape.
• Summary: The hosts introduce the setting at the Boston Fed’s 69th economic conference, noting the theme focuses on the U.S. economy amid global shifts. The current monetary policy environment is described as highly ambiguous, with market expectations for a December rate cut fluctuating significantly. The recent government shutdown has complicated the availability of clean economic data.

Labor Market vs. Inflation Balance

Copied to clipboard!

(00:07:46)

• Key Takeaway: Collins is currently more concerned about persistent inflation elevation than immediate, sharp labor market deterioration.
• Summary: Collins affirms her focus on both parts of the dual mandate, but notes softening in the labor market reflects both slowing supply and demand growth without a significant unemployment change yet. She views the previous 50 basis point cuts as appropriate positioning given the shift in the balance of risks seen over the summer. Policy is currently considered only mildly restrictive, balancing labor risks against continued inflation concerns.

Data Analysis Process

Copied to clipboard!

(00:12:12)

• Key Takeaway: Fed presidents rely on internal research teams to quickly unpack new data releases, focusing on details over headline numbers.
• Summary: When major economic data like the jobs report is released, the process involves immediate review by the local Reserve Bank’s research team to assess the details, contrasting the new information with prior data. Following this internal analysis, the President communicates with colleagues to synthesize findings.

Proliferation of Fed Speakers

Copied to clipboard!

(00:13:48)

• Key Takeaway: A high volume of Fed speakers occurs during periods of economic uncertainty to explain diverse regional viewpoints.
• Summary: The frequency of Fed speakers staking ground is attributed to the structural strength of the federated system, which brings diverse viewpoints, especially when clarity is low. Speakers have a responsibility to explain their regional information and thinking during economic turning points.

Inflation Expectations and Longevity

Copied to clipboard!

(00:18:36)

• Key Takeaway: The longevity of inflation being above target is a key factor, raising concerns about behavioral responses and potential de-anchoring of expectations.
• Summary: Collins notes that the sustained elevation of inflation, rather than just the current reading, influences behavioral analysis, as businesses may expect to continue passing on price increases. Her baseline scenario anticipates slow disinflation as tariffs work through, but she watches for scenarios where expectations become unmoored, referencing a Boston Fed paper on the 1970s parallel.

Tariffs and Price Adjustment

Copied to clipboard!

(00:23:47)

• Key Takeaway: Tariff impacts are considered a ’long one-off’ adjustment period, potentially elongated by uncertainty, and productivity gains may offset some cost increases.
• Summary: A ‘one-time’ tariff impact means the price level adjusts over months or a year, not instantly, and uncertainty can elongate this pass-through period. Analysis of the 2018 tariffs showed peak impact took five months or more, suggesting current impacts could take longer. Increased productivity, potentially aided by AI, can enable cost savings that offset tariff-related price increases.

Operational Effects of Tariffs

Copied to clipboard!

(00:28:06)

• Key Takeaway: Businesses prioritize navigating uncertainty over adjusting to a fixed tariff level, leading to an ’efficiency mindset’ in investment decisions.
• Summary: Firms find fluctuating tariff levels challenging, preferring a known, stable cost structure. This uncertainty, combined with cost increases, drives an ’efficiency mindset’ where firms invest in automation and process improvements as a ’no-regrets’ strategy. Larger firms show cautious optimism, while smaller firms report more stress.

AI Adoption and Policy Implications

Copied to clipboard!

(00:40:13)

• Key Takeaway: AI adoption is now a significant conversation topic across sectors, but its long-term impact on employment remains uncertain, echoing historical technological shifts.
• Summary: AI is being adopted broadly, from manufacturing (like sorting planks in a lumber mill) to back-office functions, with firms reporting both worker support/growth enablement and potential downsizing. Collins views AI as a general-purpose technology like electricity, expecting new jobs to emerge, though transition challenges might be faster than in past technological revolutions.

Housing Affordability and Fed Role

Copied to clipboard!

(00:45:33)

• Key Takeaway: Restoring price stability and maximum employment is the Fed’s primary way to create a conducive environment for addressing long-term housing supply challenges.
• Summary: High housing costs are a frequent concern impacting economic participation, but the Fed’s direct influence is limited. While higher rates can curb demand in the short run, they can also curtail development. The Boston Fed acts as a convener, collaborating with entities like the Harvard Center on Housing Studies to support community efforts to address affordability.